HMRC crypto data proposals raise privacy and oversight concerns

Phuong-Linh Nguyen

HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) could gain powers to request detailed records from cryptocurrency firms without first seeking tribunal approval under draft measures that remain under consideration. The proposal has prompted concerns about privacy, the scope of businesses affected and the level of parliamentary scrutiny.

The draft would extend Financial Institution Notices (FINs), which HMRC can already use to obtain information from financial institutions, to cryptoasset service providers. Under the existing rules described in the proposal, a taxpayer’s consent and tribunal sign-off are not required before HMRC issues a notice. The proposed extension would allow the tax authority to request computer records, access to software and customer transaction data directly from businesses.

The public consultation on the draft closed on 7 September. Whether the changes will be implemented remains undecided, according to the source report. Industry commentators have objected to the absence of a direct appeal process against the notices and the fact that taxpayers would not have to consent to the information requests.

Uncertainty over which firms could be covered

Recap, a UK provider of crypto tax software, has warned that the draft’s definition of businesses in scope may be broad enough to include firms that do not hold customers’ assets. Those potentially affected could include tax software developers, wallet software creators, block explorers, data vendors and hardware wallet manufacturers.

That distinction matters to the debate: these businesses may provide tools or information without managing customer funds, yet critics fear the wording could still bring them within reach of a notice. The source does not establish that any of these types of firm would definitely be included. Their status would depend on the final wording and how the measure was applied.

The draft also proposes removing HMRC’s statutory obligation to submit an annual report to Parliament on its use of FINs. Opponents argue that doing so would reduce parliamentary oversight of how frequently the notices are issued. The proposal therefore concerns both the information HMRC could obtain and the reporting available on its use of those powers.

Concerns over data linked to public wallets

Concerns over data linked to public wallets

Privacy and personal safety are central to the objections. Critics are concerned that information identifying individuals, including names, home addresses and national tax identifiers, could become linked to public Bitcoin blockchain addresses. Blockchain records are publicly visible, unlike ordinary bank records described in the report.

If identifying information were connected to particular wallet addresses and later leaked or compromised, security experts cited in the source warn that retail investors and everyday traders could face physical security risks. The report raises this as a potential consequence; it does not say that a leak has occurred or that the proposed powers would themselves publish personal data on a blockchain.

The practical issue for crypto businesses is the prospect of having to respond to information demands if the extension becomes law, while the possible reach beyond firms that custody assets remains contested. The source provides no figures for the number of businesses or customers that could be affected, and gives no market-price data for Bitcoin or other cryptoassets. The proposal is about HMRC’s access to information, not a change to crypto prices.

Part of wider UK tax and regulatory changes

Part of wider UK tax and regulatory changes

The proposed powers sit alongside other developments affecting UK crypto holders. HMRC has recently launched a separate campaign urging taxpayers to disclose undeclared gains and outstanding liabilities voluntarily before the upcoming Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework rules take effect. The source does not specify a start date for those rules.

The Financial Conduct Authority is also finalising a wider regulatory structure for digital assets, with the full regime expected to take effect in 2027, according to the report. These developments are distinct: the FIN proposal concerns HMRC’s ability to obtain records, while the FCA work concerns the regulatory framework for digital assets.

For now, the draft remains subject to a decision after the consultation, which closed on 7 September. No implementation decision is reported.